The Presence Problem No One Tells You About
- Apr 14
- 2 min read
The presence problem no one tells you about.
I want to tell you about a senior leader I coached. Let’s call her Mara.
Mara was sharp, direct, and technically excellent. She’d built a reputation for clear thinking and high standards. And for four years, she kept getting the same piece of feedback from every 360, every review, every skip-level conversation.
“She comes across as defensive.”
She couldn’t figure it out. Because from where she sat, she wasn’t being defensive. She was being rigorous. She was pushing back on ideas she thought were wrong, asking the hard questions other people were afraid to ask, holding people to commitments they’d made.
All the right things. And the room was reading it as threat.
Here’s what was actually happening. When someone challenged her thinking in a meeting, her body would tighten. Her pace would speed up. Her voice would sharpen. She’d win the argument — and the person across the table would walk out feeling diminished. Not heard. Not engaged. Diminished.
She wasn’t being defensive. But she looked defensive. And in leadership, how you land is the reality. What you intend matters — but what people experience is what shapes their decisions, their trust, their willingness to follow you.
We worked on one thing. Before anyone finished making a point she disagreed with, she would take one slow breath, drop her pace by about twenty percent, and say four words: “Tell me more about that.”
Not as a strategy. Not as a trick. As a genuine deceleration. A decision to listen before responding. To get curious before getting certain.
Within six weeks, the feedback had changed. Not because her standards changed. Not because she stopped pushing back. But because the room started experiencing her rigor as engagement instead of threat.
Here’s the principle underneath all of this: executive presence isn’t a credential or a performance style or a set of mannerisms you adopt. It’s the gap — or the absence of a gap — between what you intend and what you transmit.
And most leaders have no idea what they’re transmitting. Not because they don’t care. But because nobody has ever given them real data about how they land.
Your room is reading you all the time. Your team is reading you. Your peers are reading you. Your boss is reading you. Before you say a word, before your slide deck comes up, they’re registering your energy, your pace, your regulation.
The question is: what are they reading?
If you don’t know — that’s the place to start.
Comments