You’re Not Faking It. You’re Using an Outdated Map.
- Feb 23
- 2 min read
"I keep waiting for someone to figure out
that I don’t actually know what I’m doing at this level."
That’s a direct quote from a VP — eighteen months into a role she was headhunted for. Brilliant track record. Two decades of experience. Product launches that generated hundreds of millions in revenue. Teams built from scratch.
And she was quietly convinced it was only a matter of time before someone figured out she didn’t belong.
Her 360 feedback told a completely different story. Peers rated her one of the strongest strategic thinkers on the leadership team. Direct reports said she was the best manager they’d ever worked for. One skip-level wrote that she was the reason they stayed at the company.
She looked at those results like they were describing someone else. “They must be being nice,” she said. And she meant it.
I told her: “You just did something interesting. I gave you data from twelve people who know your work intimately, and you spent thirty seconds explaining why all twelve are wrong and you’re right. Would you accept that kind of analysis in any other domain?”
She laughed. “If a product manager brought me survey data from twelve customers and told me the data was wrong because the customers were being nice, I’d send them back to do more work.”
Here’s what I’ve come to understand after sitting with hundreds of professionals who experience this: imposter syndrome is almost always an identity lag. Your professional identity — the internal picture of who you are and where you belong — takes six to eighteen months to catch up after a significant transition. You got the new title. The person inside is still measuring against who they used to be.
You’re not faking it. You’re using an outdated map.
And the cruelest trick is how the imposter compensates. For some, it drives over-preparation — presentations three times longer than needed, every possible question researched in advance. That looks like excellence from the outside. It’s a treadmill on the inside.
For others, it drives silence. Processing every thought through so many filters that by the time they clear their own bar, the moment has passed and the conversation has moved on. That looks like thoughtfulness. It registers as invisibility.
Both versions share the same root: a gap between where you actually are and where your identity thinks you are.
The fix isn’t confidence. It’s calibration.
Where is your identity still running on the old software?
Comments